When to NOT Use AI for Cooking

Go Old School!

AI has become a versatile kitchen companion—planning menus, tracking nutrition, suggesting creative pairings—but sometimes the best cooking experiences happen without it. There are moments where stepping away from the screen and embracing the imperfections of hands-on cooking is exactly what makes food meaningful. Let’s talk about when it’s better to keep AI out of the kitchen.

The Value of Human Touch

Cooking isn’t just about getting dinner on the table—it’s about connection. A chatbot can generate a perfectly balanced menu, but it can’t replace the feeling of teaching your child how to roll out pie dough or remembering your grandmother’s exact way of seasoning a stew. Some dishes are stories passed down through time, and the “measure by feel” approach is part of the experience. AI might offer a shortcut, but it can’t replicate those intangible family traditions.

Fictional example: Imagine a family gathered on Sunday afternoon, flour dusting the counter as they shape homemade pasta. Could AI provide a recipe? Of course. But the laughter, the messy fingers, the collective sense of achievement—those come only from doing it yourself. In these moments, AI takes a backseat, and that’s exactly how it should be.

Learning Through Trial and Error

Part of becoming a better cook is failing sometimes. Overcooked vegetables, under-seasoned soups, collapsed cakes—these mishaps teach lessons you’ll remember far longer than an AI-generated correction. While AI can predict substitutions and timing, there’s real growth in figuring out why the bread didn’t rise or why the sauce split. Confidence in the kitchen is often built on mistakes, not on always getting it “right” the first time.

BONUS TIP:  No, vanilla soy milk does not work as a substitute for regular milk to make gravy...

One practical way to use this balance: let AI suggest recipes when you’re short on ideas, but occasionally set it aside. Try cooking a dish completely by memory or without measuring. You’ll build instincts that no algorithm can provide.

When Creativity Should Lead, Not Code

AI excels at finding patterns and suggesting logical pairings. But sometimes, the most fun discoveries come from spontaneous creativity. That odd mix of leftover rice, garden zucchini, and a random spice blend might not appear in any AI-generated recipe—but it could become your new favorite dish. These unplanned experiments push personal creativity and often lead to dishes with unique character.

If you want a challenge, give yourself “AI-free nights” in the kitchen: no recipe apps, no prompts, just your pantry and your imagination. It might not always be pretty, but you’ll learn new skills and build confidence in your own taste and intuition.

Closing Thoughts

AI can be a brilliant sous-chef, but it doesn’t need to run the kitchen. Human connection, trial-and-error learning, and spontaneous creativity are all essential parts of cooking that deserve their own space. Use AI as a guide when it’s helpful—but don’t be afraid to go old-school when the moment calls for it.

Reflection: When was the last time you cooked a meal completely without guidance—just instinct, memory, and creativity? Could it be time to try again?

Comments