Fan Fiction Friday: When Harry Met Alton
The following is a work of fan fiction. All characters are fictional portrayals created for entertainment. No endorsement by or affiliation with the original creators is implied.
New York City. Night Court, Part 2. Judge Harry T. Stone presides over the graveyard shift arraignment docket — a rotating parade of the baffling, the bizarre, and the occasionally brilliant. Tonight's docket includes one Alton Brown, cited for operating an unlicensed open-flame cooking apparatus on a public sidewalk in violation of three municipal codes and one fire ordinance that hasn't been invoked since 1987.
Bailiff Bull Shannon escorts the defendant to the defense table. Alton is still wearing a full-length apron and holding a clipboard.
Scene One: The Arraignment
HARRY: (squinting at the docket) The People of New York vs. Alton Brown. Charges include... unlicensed open flame, improper use of a wok ring, and — this one's new — "willful public instruction without a permit."
ALTON: That last one doesn't exist.
HARRY: It does as of last Tuesday. I wrote it myself after a man spent forty minutes explaining to a crosswalk how to properly temper chocolate. (peers over his glasses) Were you that man?
ALTON: I was giving a demonstration of Maillard reaction browning on a portable induction unit. The open flame charge is completely unfounded. Induction is electromagnetic. There is no flame.
DAN FIELDING (prosecutor, smoothing his lapels): Your Honor, the fire marshal disagrees.
ALTON: The fire marshal was standing too close to the pan. The smoke was expected. It was part of the demonstration.
HARRY: What were you demonstrating?
ALTON: The difference between fond and burning. They are not the same thing. Most people do not know this.
HARRY: (to Bull) Is that true?
BULL: (nodding slowly) I always thought my pan was broken.
Scene Two: The Plea
ATTORNEY CHRISTINE SULLIVAN (defense, shuffling papers): Your Honor, my client is a culinary educator. He was demonstrating a core cooking concept to a small crowd that had gathered voluntarily. The sidewalk permit application was filed. The city simply hadn't processed it yet.
DAN: It was filed this morning. The incident occurred last night.
ALTON: I filed it retroactively. It covers the same event.
DAN: That is not how permits work.
ALTON: That's also not how most people think about brining, but here we are.
HARRY: Mr. Brown, I want to understand something. You were standing on a public sidewalk, at eleven-thirty at night, teaching people about pan drippings?
ALTON: Fond. Not drippings. Fond is the flavorful crust left behind when proteins are seared at high heat. Drippings are rendered fat. The distinction matters enormously.
HARRY: (pause) How enormously?
ALTON: The entire flavor base of a pan sauce depends on it. If you deglaze drippings, you get greasy liquid. If you deglaze fond, you get complexity. Depth. Something worth eating.
Silence in the courtroom. Bull is taking notes on a napkin.
Scene Three: The Sentence
HARRY: Here's what I'm going to do. Mr. Brown, I'm dismissing the flame charge — induction is induction, the fire marshal should know better. The permit issue is a fine of fifty dollars, which I'm reducing to ten because you just explained something I've been doing wrong for thirty years.
DAN: Your Honor —
HARRY: Dan, when did you last make a pan sauce?
DAN: (pause) ...I have people for that.
HARRY: Exactly. (bangs gavel) However, Mr. Brown, the "willful public instruction" ordinance — which, yes, I did write — stands. Community service. Fifty hours. Teaching.
ALTON: ...Teaching what?
HARRY: (gesturing broadly at the courtroom) Whatever this room needs. Bull needs to understand why his pan isn't broken. Roz has been overcooking chicken for a decade. And I have a standing Saturday reservation at a restaurant that keeps charging me for "chef's reduction" that is clearly just burnt stock.
ALTON: (looking at the docket, then the room, then his clipboard) Do you have a kitchen here?
BULL: There's a microwave in the break room.
ALTON: (long pause) We'll work with it.
HARRY: (grinning) Night Court is now in session — and apparently, in class. (bangs gavel)
Next week on Night Court: Alton attempts to explain knife skills to the holding cell. Mac takes notes. Dan insists foie gras is a legal defense strategy. Bull achieves a perfect pan sauce on his first try.
Comments